Human virtual assistants cost $15-25/hour and work during business hours. KallyAI starts at $19/month and works 24/7. Here is when each makes sense.
Human virtual assistants (VAs) are remote workers who handle administrative tasks on your behalf. Typically hired through platforms like Upwork, Belay, or Time Etc, they charge $15-25/hour for US-based assistants (or $5-10/hour for overseas VAs) and handle tasks like phone calls, email management, scheduling, research, and data entry.
The key advantage of human VAs is their ability to handle nuanced, context-rich tasks. They can read social cues in conversations, exercise judgment in ambiguous situations, and build relationships on your behalf. A good human VA becomes more effective over time as they learn your preferences.
The downsides are cost, management overhead, and availability. You pay for their time on hold (which can be 30-60 minutes for insurance or government calls), need to train them on your preferences, manage their work, and they only work during their scheduled hours.
| Feature | KallyAI | Human Virtual Assistants | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phone calls | AI-powered, instant start | Human-made during business hours | K |
| Hold time cost | Credits-based (~6 credits/min) | $15-25/hr while waiting on hold | K |
| Availability | 24/7 | Business hours only | K |
| Email handling | Task-based email sending | Full inbox management | C |
| IVR navigation | Automated | Manual — you pay for the time | K |
| Nuanced conversations | Limited to AI capabilities | Human judgment and empathy | C |
| Management overhead | None — describe task and go | Training, check-ins, feedback needed | K |
| Consistency | Same quality every time | Varies by VA, day, and workload | K |
| Transcripts | Automatic for every call | Manual notes, may miss details | K |
| Complex research | AI-powered research + calls | Human research with judgment | = |
| Cost (10 calls/month) | ~$19/mo (Starter plan) | ~$150-500/mo (10-20 hrs) | K |
| Scaling | Handles multiple tasks simultaneously | One task at a time | K |
Starts at $19/mo for 200 credits. A typical appointment booking costs ~30-40 credits. Pro plan at $49/mo for 600 credits.
$15-25/hr for US-based VAs. A single 30-minute call (including hold time) costs $7.50-12.50. Monthly minimums of 10-20 hours ($150-500/mo) are common.
| Area | KallyAI | Human Virtual Assistants |
|---|---|---|
| Cost model | Fixed monthly + credits per task | Hourly rate, including hold and admin time |
| Speed to start | Instant — no hiring or training | Days to weeks for hiring and onboarding |
| Task types | Calls, emails, research, coordination | Anything a human can do remotely |
| Judgment calls | AI-level decision making | Human judgment, empathy, and nuance |
| Reliability | Always available, consistent quality | Subject to human factors (sick days, turnover) |
For routine administrative tasks — making phone calls, scheduling appointments, getting vendor quotes, navigating IVR systems, and sitting on hold — KallyAI delivers better value than human virtual assistants at a fraction of the cost. You do not need to pay someone $20/hour to sit on hold for 45 minutes.
Human VAs remain superior for tasks requiring judgment, empathy, relationship management, and complex decision-making. If you need someone to handle a sensitive conversation with a difficult client or manage an ongoing project with multiple stakeholders, a human VA is the right choice.
The practical approach for most people: use KallyAI for the 80% of admin tasks that are routine and process-driven. Reserve human assistance for the 20% that genuinely requires a human touch.
For routine phone calls, appointments, and vendor research — yes. For complex tasks requiring human judgment, inbox management, and relationship building — not yet. Many people use KallyAI to reduce the hours they need from a human VA.
If you currently spend $300-500/month on a human VA primarily for phone calls and scheduling, KallyAI at $19-49/month could save you $250-450/month. The savings are largest when your VA spends significant time on hold.
It depends on your tasks. If most of your admin work is phone calls, appointments, and research, KallyAI may be sufficient. If you need inbox management, project coordination, and nuanced communication, you may still want a human VA for those specific tasks.
Yes. KallyAI's AI handles natural conversations, navigates IVR menus, and communicates clearly with businesses. You receive full transcripts so you can verify every interaction.
See why people choose KallyAI over Human Virtual Assistants. Try for $1 with 100 credits and money-back guarantee.
Try KallyAI for $1