Magic AI pairs human assistants with AI tools at executive-level pricing billed every 4 weeks. KallyAI delivers AI-powered task execution starting at $19/month. Which model works for you?
Magic AI is a premium executive assistant service that combines human assistants with AI tools. Clients are matched with dedicated human assistants who use AI-powered tools to handle tasks like email management, travel booking, research, and calendar management.
Magic positions itself as the executive assistant for busy leaders and high-net-worth individuals. The human element means Magic can handle nuanced tasks requiring judgment, relationship management, and complex coordination that pure AI struggles with.
The tradeoff is cost and speed. Magic pricing is weekly (for example, $199/week for Magic 24/7 with 10 hours/week, plus higher weekly rates for 20-hour and 40-hour dedicated assistants), billed every 4 weeks. It requires onboarding time and operates during business hours. Tasks that require a human to coordinate, wait on hold, or make judgment calls happen at human pace.
| Feature | KallyAI | Magic AI | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phone calls | AI makes calls instantly | Human makes calls during business hours | K |
| Email management | Sends emails as part of tasks | Full inbox management | C |
| Travel booking | Research + calls for bookings | Full travel coordination | C |
| IVR navigation | Automated IVR handling | Human navigates manually | K |
| Hold time handling | AI waits — costs credits, not hours | Human waits — you pay for their time | K |
| Availability | 24/7 | Business hours, time zone dependent | K |
| Speed | Instant task start | Depends on assistant availability | K |
| Nuanced judgment | Limited to AI capabilities | Human judgment and relationship skills | C |
| Relationship building | No | Yes — human touch | C |
| Call transcripts | Yes — automatic | Notes/summaries from assistant | K |
| Cost | Starting at $19/mo | Weekly pricing billed every 4 weeks | K |
| Onboarding time | None — start immediately | Days to weeks for assistant matching | K |
Starts at $19/mo for 200 credits (~5-6 calls). Power plan $99/mo for 1,500 credits. Paid trial: $1 for 100 credits.
Weekly pricing billed every 4 weeks: $199/week for Magic 24/7 (10 hrs/week), $270/week for 20 hrs/week, and $540/week for 40 hrs/week.
| Area | KallyAI | Magic AI |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Pure AI — automated task execution | Human + AI — dedicated assistant |
| Cost | $19-299/mo depending on usage | Weekly pricing billed every 4 weeks |
| Best tasks | Routine calls, appointments, vendor research, follow-ups | Complex coordination, travel, inbox management, relationship tasks |
| Speed | Instant start, AI pace | Human pace, business hours |
| Scalability | Handles multiple tasks simultaneously | One assistant, one task at a time |
Magic AI and KallyAI represent opposite ends of the assistant spectrum. Magic provides human-level judgment and relationship skills at executive pricing. KallyAI provides AI-powered speed and availability at consumer pricing.
For routine admin tasks — scheduling appointments, getting vendor quotes, handling IVR menus, sitting on hold — KallyAI delivers equivalent or better results at a fraction of the cost. You do not need a human to wait on hold for 45 minutes or press "1" for English.
For tasks requiring nuance, judgment, and relationship management, Magic AI justifies its premium. The best approach for many professionals is starting with KallyAI for routine tasks and upgrading to Magic only if they truly need the human element.
For routine tasks like phone calls, appointments, and vendor research, KallyAI often performs better — faster start, no hold-time cost, 24/7 availability. For complex tasks requiring judgment and relationships, a human assistant is still superior.
Magic uses human assistants who make calls during business hours. There may be delay depending on assistant availability. KallyAI starts calls immediately upon approval.
Magic employs dedicated human assistants. The cost covers their salary, benefits, training, and management overhead. KallyAI uses AI for execution, which scales without per-hour human costs.
Yes. Many KallyAI users previously used human assistants and switched for the cost savings and instant availability. You can start with the $1 trial (100 credits) to test before committing.
See why people choose KallyAI over Magic AI. Try for $1 with 100 credits and money-back guarantee.
Try KallyAI for $1